Live
Read now

General Physician, PC

Family Medicine • East Aurora, NY

4.6/5(96 reviews)

Information from public sources; not independently verified. Confirm hours, insurance and appointment availability with the clinic.

Last gathered July 11, 2026. How our information is sourced · Report incorrect information

Services Offered

Not published.

Insurance & Payment

Not published.

Languages Spoken

Not published.

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed

  • Healthgrades (Dr. Kevin McMahon): 4.5/5 stars based on 19 reviews (19)
  • US News Doctors (Dr. Elizabeth Weingarten): 5/5 stars based on 53 reviews (53)
  • Vitals (Dr. Elizabeth Weingarten): 3.9/5 stars (8 reviews (sampled))
  • Vitals (Dr. Shawn Cotton): 3.6/5 stars (9 reviews (sampled))
  • Vitals (Dr. David Lawton): 3.8/5 stars (7 reviews (sampled))

Patients praise

  • Many patients describe the physicians as thorough, caring, knowledgeable, and good listeners
  • High appreciation for doctors who take the time to build relationships and demonstrate genuine concern for overall well-being
  • Some staff and nurses are described as caring and friendly by certain patients

Common complaints

  • Frequent complaints regarding difficulty reaching the office by phone and long hold times
  • Reports of rude, unprofessional, or unresponsive administrative and nursing staff
  • Frustration with administrative processes and communication failures between providers and patients
  • Occasional reports of patients being discharged from the practice with little or no explanation

"Dr. McMahon is very thorough and listens. Not rushed and easy to talk to. I have been going to him for over 30 years."

- Healthgrades

"If you call it is a guaranteed 20 minute wait to be put on another 10 minute+ hold. You will then be talked down at and what you ask them to do will not be done right if done at all."

- LocalityBiz

"Dr. Weingarten takes the time to listen and work WITH me. She is polite, friendly and geniunely concerned about my wellbeing. Finally, a doctor who cares about her patients."

- Vitals

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 - sources: [1][2][3][4].

Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.

Other family medicine clinics in East Aurora

Related articles

Comparing your options?

See other family medicine clinics in East Aurora, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.

More Family Medicine Clinics
ClinAdsby ClinsightBuilt for clinicsYour clinic's marketing team, powered by AI.On-brand ads, SEO, and social campaigns in one place.Generate your first clinic ad for free Clincyby ClinsightBuilt for dental clinicsGet more revenue from the patients you already have.Clincy calls and texts lapsed patients until they're back on the schedule.Book a call DDS RecruitPowered by ClinsightDental recruitingYour practice's fractional recruiting team.Dental-only search, run end to end, with placements guaranteed for a year.Find your next hire

Clinic and healthcare updates

Get updates in your inbox. Subscribing is optional.