
Garnet Health
Obstetrics & Gynecology • Middletown, NY • 3 (Middletown, Harris, Callicoon) locations
Information from public sources; not independently verified. Confirm hours, insurance and appointment availability with the clinic.
Last gathered July 11, 2026. How our information is sourced · Report incorrect information
About
Garnet Health offers Obstetrics & Gynecology services through its Middletown-based network. Key points: - Organization: Nonprofit healthcare system headquartered in Middletown, NY, serving Orange and Sullivan Counties and surrounding areas. - Services: Broad medical offerings including OB/GYN as part of Garnet Health Doctors and affiliated centers; emphasis on expanding specialty programs and local care. - Locations: Primary presence in Middletown, NY, with related Garnet Health Doctors/medical centers in the region. - Access: OB/GYN services announced to begin at Garnet Health Doctors in Harris, Sullivan County, with appointments starting July 1 (indicating ongoing expansion of OB/GYN care within the system). - Contact: Main line and general inquiries via contact@garnethealth.org or 845-333-1000.
Services Offered
Team
Insurance & Payment
Not published.
Languages Spoken
Not published.
Photos
Photos published by Garnet Health showing the obstetrics & gynecology practice in Middletown, NY.








What Patients Say
Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed
- Healthgrades (Dr. Lillian Kaminsky): 1.7 out of 5 stars (40 ratings) (40 reviews)
- U.S. News & World Report (Provider profiles): 3.9 to 5 out of 5 stars (varies by provider) (Varies by provider)
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) quality assessment: 91.1 out of 100 (CMS quality score) (Not applicable (Institutional metric))
Patients praise
- High praise for the clinical staff at the Rowley Family Birthing Center (nurses, doctors, and support staff)
- Reports of kind, professional, and knowledgeable care during delivery experiences
- Positive feedback on hospital food choices
Common complaints
- Reports of unprofessional, rude, or cold demeanor by some providers
- Difficulties with office staff, phone communication, and appointment scheduling
- Concerns about rushed appointments and lack of patient engagement
- Complaints regarding hospital amenities such as uncomfortable beds and spouse sleeping accommodations
- Mixed feedback on nursing staff performance
"Very cold and quick to rush you out of her office. And if you ask too many questions, she gets an attitude."
- Patient review of Ronica Bennett, CM (Healthgrades)"The staff is phenomenal. They are attentive, caring, and provide support. We had all 3 of our children delivered there."
- Patient review of Rowley Family Birthing Center (LocalityBiz)"Unprofessional, rude, unorganized, and constant problems is the summary of my experience. Do not waste your time going there."
- Patient review of Dr. Judith A. Stavis (Vitals)Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 - sources: [1][2][3][4].
In the News
- Crystal Run Abruptly Closes OB-GYN Clinic, Leaving Just 1 OB-GYN in Sullivan County - Radio Catskill - May 6, 2026
- Garnet Health Says Planned Montefiore Affiliation Will Strengthen Local Care, Preserve Services - Radio Catskill - Oct 27, 2025
- Garnet Health Doctors Welcomes Psychiatrist Gulnaz Kiyamova, MD | Garnet Health | Mid-Hudson Healthcare System | Hospitals in Middletown, Harris and Callicoon, NY - Dec 26, 2025
- Garnet Health Welcomes New Providers to Urgent Care and Urology | Garnet Health | Mid-Hudson Healthcare System | Hospitals in Middletown, Harris and Callicoon, NY - Feb 10, 2026
- Garnet Health Announces Restructuring | Garnet Health | Mid-Hudson Healthcare System | Hospitals in Middletown, Harris and Callicoon, NY - Jul 17, 2025
Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.
Other obstetrics & gynecology clinics in Middletown
Related articles
Comparing your options?
See other obstetrics & gynecology clinics in Middletown, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.

