
Carlson-Tillisch Eye Clinic
Eye Care/Optometry Clinic • New Ulm, MN • Since 1909 • 2 (Mankato and New Ulm) locations
Information from public sources; not independently verified. Confirm hours, insurance and appointment availability with the clinic.
Last gathered July 11, 2026. How our information is sourced · Report incorrect information
About
Carlson-Tillisch Eye Clinic is an optometry practice serving Mankato and New Ulm, Minnesota, founded in 1909. The clinic offers comprehensive eye care and eyewear, using up-to-date technology and personalized solutions. Key details: - Locations: 4 offices in Minnesota (Mankato and New Ulm) - Services: comprehensive eye exams, eyewear, contact lenses, eye disease management (glaucoma, diabetic eye disease, dry eye, computer vision, etc.), Ortho-K, scleral lenses, Optomap imaging - Ownership/Structure: Private partnership; founder roots over a century; current leaders include Murphy Grotewold (Optometrist/Owner) and Tami Gay (Director) - Contact: main numbers available; HQ at 120 N Broad St, Mankato, MN 56001 - Online presence: carlsontillisch.com; modest web traffic; active in local community
Services Offered
Insurance & Payment
Not published.
Languages Spoken
Not published.
FAQs
What services does Carlson-Tillisch Eye Clinic offer?
Thorough prescription eye exam, comprehensive contact lens exam, same-day eyewear on some prescriptions, and a huge selection of frames and sunglasses.
How can I make an appointment?
To make an appointment, you may schedule online or call the Mankato office at 507-345-5087 or New Ulm at 507-354-7407.
Social Media
Photos
Photos published by Carlson-Tillisch Eye Clinic showing the eye care/optometry clinic practice in New Ulm, MN.








What Patients Say
Overall sentiment across review platforms: positive
- Yelp / Apple Maps aggregate: Approximately 3.0 to 3.2 stars (varies by platform) (8-9 reviews (on specific aggregate platforms))
- Optix-Now: 5.0 stars (1 written review (as of Oct 2025))
Patients praise
- Friendly, caring, and professional staff
- Thorough and efficient eye exams
- High-quality, modern equipment
- Long-standing local reputation and personalized patient attention
Common complaints
- High pricing for eye exams and eyewear compared to retail alternatives
- Limited selection of frames in certain price ranges
- Potential delays or dissatisfaction regarding specialized eyewear orders
"$180 for a simple eye exam. I'll stick with costco or walmart. Lenses would be $400 and I got have a complicated lens. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable but these prices!"
- Patricio F. via Yelp/MapQuest"I saw Dr. Tracye Rasmussen (Eiselt) on January 13, 2024 for an exam and wow -- I was impressed with her and this clinic from the minute I stepped in the door. I was quickly and warmly greeted by..."
- Robin C. via Apple Maps/Yelp"Staff and doctors are very friendly. Up to date equipment is amazing!!"
- Carlson-Tillisch Testimonials pageSynthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 - sources: [1][2][3][4].
Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.
Other eye care/optometry clinic clinics in New Ulm
Related articles
Comparing your options?
See other eye care/optometry clinic clinics in New Ulm, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.

