Costello Eye Physicians & Surgeons
Surgery • Herkimer, NY
Information from public sources; not independently verified. Confirm hours, insurance and appointment availability with the clinic.
Last gathered July 11, 2026. How our information is sourced · Report incorrect information
About
Costello Eye Physicians & Surgeons, PLLC is a small ophthalmology practice based in Oneida, NY, with 9 employees. They offer advanced surgical and medical eye care from a team of ophthalmologists and optometrists and serve the Mohawk Valley region. The provided page lists company details and workforce composition but does not specify a Herkimer office location. If you need confirmation of a Herkimer office, you may want to contact them directly through costelloeye.com or LinkedIn.
Services Offered
Technology & Equipment
Team
Insurance & Payment
Not published.
Cash, Credit cards, CareCredit financing
Financing: CareCredit financing available; Payment plans may be available
Languages Spoken
Pricing
Current Offers
New patient offer - Not specified (expires Not specified)
FAQs
What are the hours?
Monday – Friday: 8:00am–5:00pm
Photos
Photos published by Costello Eye Physicians & Surgeons showing the surgery practice in Herkimer, NY.
What Patients Say
Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed
- Healthgrades: 3.7/5 stars (3 reviews (Healthgrades))
- Birdeye: 3.3/5 stars (40 reviews (Birdeye))
- WebMD (Dr. John Costello): 4.5/5 stars (39 ratings (WebMD))
- WebMD (Dr. Patrick Costello): 4.0/5 stars (42 ratings (WebMD))
Patients praise
- High satisfaction with cataract surgery results and vision improvement
- Surgeons described as skilled, professional, and knowledgeable
- Effective pre- and post-operative care and explanations of procedures
- Friendly and professional staff interactions (when not related to wait times)
Common complaints
- Long wait times for appointments
- Issues with office organization and scheduling efficiency
- Reports of crowded waiting areas
- Occasional dissatisfaction with communication or staff interaction
"Very pleased with Dr. John Costello. He did both of my eyes for cataract surgery... My vision is now as it was when I was actually wearing my glasses. Yay!"
- Birdeye Review"The biggest drawback is office organization. Waiting an hour and a half for a ten minute visit doesn't seem too considerate to the patients - especially as so many are elderly."
- Birdeye Review"I now have 20-20 vision for the first time in my life and only wish I had done it sooner. I recommend his with complete confidence."
- WebMD ReviewSynthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 - sources: [1][2][3][4].
In the News
- Dr. Daniel F. Colino - Optometrist in Hamilton, NY - May 14, 2026
- Herkimer County Preschool Children Eligible for Free Glasses through CABVI Initiative | CABVI - Dec 1, 2025
- Dr. Kimberly A. Wadas, OD - Optometrist in Whitesboro, NY - May 14, 2026
- Samantha Austin, FNP - Nurse Practitioner in Herkimer, NY - May 14, 2026
- Elizabeth N. Kimani - Nurse Practitioner in Herkimer, NY - May 14, 2026
Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.
Other surgery clinics in Herkimer
Comparing your options?
See other surgery clinics in Herkimer, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.
